What the guidelines and the literature say
According to PubMed, four references frame percutaneous ablation of small kidney tumours:
- CIRSE, 2017 (Krokidis et al., Cardiovasc Intervent Radiol): guidelines of the European interventional radiology society on percutaneous ablation of small renal cell carcinoma. PubMed · DOI
- SIR, 2020 (Morris et al., J Vasc Interv Radiol): position statement of the Society of Interventional Radiology, endorsed by CAIR and SIO, on the role of percutaneous ablation in renal cell carcinoma. PubMed · DOI
- Shakeri and Raman, 2019 (Semin Intervent Radiol): T1a tumours tend to be low grade and slow growing; thermal ablation shows favourable complication and kidney-preservation rates compared with surgery. The authors note, however, that most studies are single-centre case series and that meta-analyses and long-term prospective comparative series are lacking. PubMed · DOI
- Chan et al., Int J Surg 2021 (meta-analysis, 32 observational studies and 1 randomised trial, 74,946 patients, ablation versus partial nephrectomy): in T1a tumours, similar local recurrence-free and cancer-specific survival, fewer postoperative complications (RR 0.72) and a smaller decline in glomerular filtration rate. Overall survival was lower after ablation, patients treated with ablation being on average 5.7 years older. Low-quality evidence: the authors conclude that ablation is a reasonable alternative in frail patients or those with comorbidities. PubMed · DOI
Our team's position: for tumours under 4 cm, cryoablation is the technique we favour. The choice between ablation, surgery and surveillance is made case by case, in a multidisciplinary team meeting.
Frequently asked questions
I found a kidney mass by chance on a scan: is it necessarily cancer?
No. A kidney mass can be a cyst, a benign tumour or a cancer. Imaging (CT, MRI, sometimes biopsy) clarifies its nature before any decision. Learn more about a kidney mass found on CT.
Is a biopsy needed before cryoablation of a kidney tumour?
A biopsy may be offered to confirm the nature of the tumour, before or during the procedure. It is not always necessary: the decision is made at consultation and in a multidisciplinary team meeting, according to the imaging and your situation. Learn more about kidney biopsy.
Who decides between cryoablation, surgery and surveillance for a kidney tumour?
The decision is made jointly in a multidisciplinary team meeting (urologist, interventional radiologist, oncologist, nephrologist), taking into account the size and location of the tumour, your general health, your kidney function and your preferences.
How do I book a kidney cryoablation consultation in Paris?
Use the contact form to send your CT or MRI (images and report) and, if possible, a letter from your doctor or urologist (attachments accepted: PDF/JPG/PNG up to 10 MB). The interventional radiology team at Cochin Hospital AP-HP (Pr Anthony Dohan) replies within 48 working hours. No referral letter is required; one is welcome if you have it.
Why this page is trustworthy
Written by the Interventional Radiology team at Cochin Hospital AP-HP, Université Paris Cité. Medically reviewed by an interventional radiologist of the department. Last updated: August 2026.
